If you converted to a Roth or sold appreciated investments this fall, the federal tax on that income was due in four installments during the year, and three of those dates had passed before you acted. Tax withheld from an IRA distribution by December 31 counts as if it had been paid evenly all year. An estimated payment sent for the January 15, 2027 deadline counts only from the day you pay it.
Which one you use decides whether you owe an underpayment penalty on the conversion.
The IRS expects to be paid during the year
Federal income tax is due as you earn the income. For 2026 there are four due dates: April 15, June 15 and September 15 of 2026, and January 15, 2027. A quarter of your required payment for the year is due on each one.
Fall short on any date and you pay a penalty on the shortfall, running from that date until the tax is paid. The penalty is interest. The IRS rate is 7% a year for the fourth quarter of 2026, and it was 7% for most of the year.
You owe no penalty if your withholding and on-time estimated payments add up to the smaller of two numbers:
90% of your 2026 tax, or
100% of the tax on your 2025 return. That becomes 110% if your 2025 adjusted gross income was over $150,000.
There is also no penalty if you owe less than $1,000 with the return.
A Roth conversion in October raises your 2026 tax in one step. If you were counting on the 90% test, the target moved after three of the four due dates had passed.
Why withholding and estimated payments are treated differently
An estimated payment is credited on the day you make it. A payment on January 15 covers the January installment and does nothing for the April, June and September dates you already missed.
Withholding follows a different rule. The IRS treats tax withheld during the year as paid in four equal parts on the four due dates, no matter when it was withheld, unless you choose to use the actual dates. So $6,000 withheld on December 20 counts as $1,500 paid on each due date, including the one last April.
For a retiree, the easiest place to find withholding is an IRA distribution. The default withholding on an IRA withdrawal is 10%, and Form W-4R lets you choose any rate from 0% to 100%. A required minimum distribution counts. The distribution has to be paid in 2026, so in practice ask your custodian by mid-December.
Two cautions:
Do not withhold from the conversion itself. Every dollar withheld is a dollar that never reaches the Roth. The conversion sizing post explains why the tax is better paid from outside cash.
An extra distribution is extra income. Taking money out of the IRA only to withhold on it raises the tax you are trying to cover. The cleaner move is a higher withholding rate on a distribution you were going to take anyway, with savings covering the spending gap.
A worked example with 2026 numbers
Take a married couple in Scottsdale, both 67. He retired at the end of 2025. Their 2026 income is a $70,000 pension and $60,000 of IRA withdrawals, taken as $30,000 in June and $30,000 in December.
Their withholding is $7,000 from the pension and 10% from each IRA withdrawal, so $13,000 for the year. Without a conversion, their taxable income is $82,500 and their federal tax is about $9,404. They were headed for a refund.
In October they convert $60,000 to a Roth. Income rises to $190,000. That is $40,000 over the line where the $6,000 senior deduction starts to phase out, so they lose $4,800 of it. Taxable income becomes $147,300 and federal tax becomes about $21,830. The conversion costs $12,426.
Now run the two tests. Their 2025 return was a full working year: income well over $150,000 and $38,000 of tax. The prior-year test requires 110% of that, or $41,800, which is no help. So they need 90% of 2026 tax, or $19,647. Planned withholding is $13,000. They are $6,647 short, which is about $1,662 on each of the four due dates.
They have three choices.
Do nothing and pay in April. The penalty runs on all four shortfalls until April 15, 2027. It comes to about $300.
Send $6,647 as an estimated payment by January 15. The April, June and September shortfalls were still late. The penalty is about $190.
Raise the withholding on the December IRA withdrawal. They file a new W-4R at 33% instead of 10%. The custodian withholds $9,900 from the $30,000 instead of $3,000. Total withholding for the year is $19,900, which clears the $19,647 target on every due date. The penalty is zero. They receive $6,900 less cash in December, cover it from savings, and owe about $1,930 with the return in April.
There is one more route. Form 2210 has an annualized income method that matches each installment to the income you had received by that date. It can remove the penalty when income arrives late in the year, and it makes a January 15 payment work. It takes a period-by-period reconstruction of the year on your return. Withholding gets the same result with one form.
Check the prior-year test first
Change one fact. Suppose 2025 had been an ordinary retirement year for this couple, with income under $150,000 and $9,800 of tax.
Their $13,000 of withholding already exceeds 100% of last year's tax. They owe no penalty at all. The remaining $8,830 is due with the return by April 15, and nothing has to change in December.
So pull your 2025 return first. If your withholding already covers last year's tax, you may only need the cash ready in April. The test tends to fail in the first year or two of retirement, when the prior year still carries a salary.
Arizona has its own version
Arizona taxes the conversion at 2.5%. On $60,000 that is $1,500.
Arizona requires estimated payments when your Arizona gross income is over $150,000 on a joint return, or $75,000 otherwise, in both the current and the prior year. This couple qualifies, because both years are over the line. The state test is 90% of this year's tax or 100% of last year's, and Arizona withholding counts toward it.
Arizona withholding on IRA distributions is voluntary. You request it from your custodian on Arizona Form A-4P. If you are raising federal withholding on a December distribution, set the Arizona election at the same time.
What it costs to get this wrong
For the couple above, about $300 in federal penalty, plus Arizona's. That will not ruin anyone, and one form avoids it.
The mistakes around it cost more. Withholding 20% from the conversion itself would have kept $12,000 out of the Roth for good. Taking an extra IRA distribution only to cover the tax adds income taxed at 22% or more. And a couple who learns in April that they owe $8,830 they did not set aside can end up paying it from the IRA, which starts the problem again in 2027.
The same rules apply if your fall income came from realizing capital gains instead of a conversion.
I am an Enrolled Agent, admitted to practice before the Internal Revenue Service, and I prepare returns alongside the planning work, so the person who sized the conversion is the one who checks how the tax gets paid.
If you want your 2026 withholding checked against both tests before December 31, that is a conversation worth having.
Aaron Randak, CFP®, EA · Golden Acre Wealth Management · Scottsdale, Arizona
Golden Acre LLC dba Golden Acre Wealth Management is an investment adviser registered with the Arizona Corporation Commission, CRD #337930. This article is educational and is not individualized tax, investment, or legal advice. Tax rules change and their application depends on your specific circumstances. Penalty amounts are estimates that assume a 7% annual rate through April 15, 2027; the IRS sets the rate each quarter.